Wednesday, December 6, 2023

Character Progression and OSR Games

 After recently finishing a 12-session Shadow Dark RPG campaign my players and I debriefed about what we liked and didn't like compared to our normal fantasy RPG of choice, D&D 5e. We came to the conclusion that we really liked the following:

  • Because combat is so dangerous, just swinging your sword is not the first thing you think of when you get into conflict. The system inadvertently encouraged talking (even though there aren't social RP mechanics).
  • Combat felt tactical. You actually had to worry about positioning, and taking actions in combat that would change the playing field and environment not just reduce HP.
  • Exploring felt fun, because your resources mattered. It's almost a meta-combat against the environment. Instead of just tracking HP you had to track rations and torches and the risk-reward of adventuring felt real.
  • They felt MORE attached to their characters than in the previous few 5e campaigns because they knew they had to work to keep them alive. 
However, there was one glaring dislike.
  • There was no real character progression outside of numerical bits. They sorely missed getting new character powers to add to their character sheet.
This got me thinking ahead for the next game I DM. I want to square the circle of character progression in an OSR-style game (for my group). To do this, I think I will steal the Dungeon Crawl Classics philosophy of "quest for it". So I want to provide quest tables for potential "powers" that players want. Each is a reward for a task. What is nice about this is the non-linearity of character progression. A thief can quest for thief powers, wizard powers, or fighter powers. It would potentially enhance their current play style or let them lean into another. 

  1. Spells: Search for a wizard who can train you/grant you this boon and complete a task that he needs a group of adventurers for.
    1. The thief wants to be able to cast invisibility so they can go super-stealth. 
    2. The cleric wants to harness the power of the Sun god by adding fireball to their spell list.
    3. The warrior wants to be able to impress the court at the next feast, so he seeks charm person.
    4. The wizard wants to be able to alter his magic formulas and change the elemental damage of any elemental spell as they prepare it.
  2. Fighting Skills: Prove yourself in combat to the master-at-arms in a local militia or seek out a legendary warrior to train you on the top of a mountain.
    1. The thief wants to be able to cross swords with the best of them, so he seeks out the swashbuckling pirate-king to train him.
    2. The cleric wants to not only cast out demons but smite them back to hell, so they seek out the training of a legendary holy warrior or travel to the site of a holy warrior-saint and pray for the blessing.
    3. The warrior wants to feel the battle fury that is sung about in the songs, so he seeks the blessing of the warrior gods or takes part in the rituals of the warrior culture.
    4. The wizard has heard of those who can weave their spells with blades and seeks the blade-singing master to teach them these secrets.
The list could go on and on. I know that this is primarily the purpose of magic items in old-school games, but new-school players don't really know that, so I think this helps bridge that gap between "I want to add a new power to my character sheet" and "go find your powers in the world". I also don't think any of these should be a menu provided for the characters. It should be taken one at a time, and as the player wants it. These are also permeant in playtest, so feel free to adjust it since there really is no guidance on what some of these powers would look like translated. Lastly, don't try and port mechanics, port vibes, and use the mechanics of whatever game you are playing to elicit the vibe of the power the character wants. 

Sunday, November 12, 2023

Planescape Redux - Through the first Planar Portal

 Last time, I decided that Theros would be the destination of the first Omenpath. This is fun for two reasons. There are many packs to crack to generate an adventure, but there is also a 5e book for Theros (Mythic Odysseys of Theros or MOoT) that we can mine for goodies!

So far our adventure has a few angles we could lean into. 

  1. The Harpers are acting like the Planar Police and are gathering the keys to and researching more information about these Omenpaths.
  2. Bane, the Lord of Darkness has an active cult in the Forgotten Realms that the players have already crossed once. For some reason, they too are interested in the Omenpaths. 
We don't need to get into #2 at the moment, luckily. I think it is best to let the campaign breathe for a while, no need to set up some end-game threat quite yet. But we can keep this cult in our back pocket for later. Let's start this Theros adventure by cracking a pack from the original Theros set.


This is a great pack. I think it would be great if the Omenpath the characters took opened up into a mountain range depicted in the land card. In these mountains lives an evil Gorgon, Hythonia the Cruel, and a Stoneshock Giant. 

When the characters are getting their bearings and journeying around the mountains the following encounters will be great to fill out a potential hex map around the mountains. The number of creatures per encounter totally depends on the level of the party you are running this for.
  • Returned Phalanx - The Returned have four stat blocks in MOoT from CR 1/4 to 4. Lore-wise the Returned are quite literally people who have returned from the dead. The mask is left over from their funeral rites.
  • Soldiers - Allied soldiers from the nearby town who are out hunting Hythonia.
    • Led by a human named Elias who was sent on a scouting mission to find the cave of Hythonia.
  • Blood-Toil Harpy - This is actually a CR 1/8 creature from MOoT.
  • Two-Headed Cerberus - What better way to kick off a Greek-themed adventure than with an encounter with a Cerberus! It helps that it is also a CR 2 creature in MOoT.
I don't see any inspiration for villages or towns. But I'm sure we can turn to MOoT for that. After looking at the world map, I've settled on using Akros as the nearby town. I like it because it's basically Sparta, so it is easy to imagine. It's also geographically next to a mountain range which fits right in. 

So in summary, this is what this pack has given us for our next adventure:
    After the characters pass through the Omenpath, they come out on the other side deep within the mountains. They begin to get their bearings and some marching Returned come across their path. From here, you'd really only need 3 hexes of mountains, put a harpy nest in one, soldier camp in one, Hythonia's Cave in one, and have the Cerberus be a wandering monster they see off in the distance that is tracking them over time. Once they meet and hopefully offer to help the soldiers from Akros, they will lead them back to town once Hythonia is taken care of or scouted (the goal would depend on the level of the party if they could handle taking her down right now).

The only thing left to do is grab a map for Hythonia's Cave and put some encounters in it just in case the players decide to go head first. My favorite place to get maps is from Dyson Logos' blog Dyson's Dodecahedron. A quick Ctr+F and "cave" search led me to this beauty called "Gloomforge Caverns"
I typically don't do a lot of work when keying my dungeons but I do like to do the following:
  • Sight: Dimly lit from sconces with a green flame.
  • Smell: Mildew mixed with a harsh tinge of sulfur.
  • Sound: Mostly silent, something sliding across a rock surface can be heard from all around. The faint echo of a snake's hiss can also be heard.
  1. Entrance Room: Pharika's Mender from our pack is great here. This card tells me that she is going to be reanimating dead things and artifacts. Let's combine that, in this room, there will be statues of fallen warriors who succumbed to Hythonia's Gaze. The gorgon here, Pharika's Mender will reawaken them by weaving magic from the green flames around the room. 
  2. The South Western Cavern: This could be a large snake nest similar to the ones shown in the card above named "Viper's Kiss".
  3. The Central Chamber: This is where Hythonia is. This will be a shrine room to Pharika, the God of Affliction. 
  4. The Eastern Chamber: Treasure Room: Have the northern entrance be a secret entrance but an obvious exit. For loot, we can add some gold based on the system you are using and the appropriate level, as for items I will open a few more packs and see what we get. 
              Prowler's Helm: A helm that casts Pass Without Trace once per day.
              God's Willing: Once per day, at dawn, you roll a d20 and store the number in the sword. As a reaction, you can replace the result on any d20 roll by you or against you in combat. 

This easily gives us 1 to 3 sessions worth of material. From here they will travel to Akros and go from there!

- Daniel


Sunday, November 5, 2023

Alternatives to Planescape

 The recent release of Planescape left a lot to be desired for me. But, this is not a review of that product. Instead, I want to continue using Magic the Gathering to inspire my D&D game. I want to start with a disclaimer: I am not an MTG lore expert. This is not an attempt to port a mechanic or lore from MTG directly to 5e. The goal of this is to use the ideas laid out in the Magic lore to enhance our D&D games. Also, I do not DM my games with an entire campaign-spanning adventure in mind. I run 1-3 session adventures that may or may not have a throughline. The characters stay the same, but for me, a campaign is a collection of adventures, not one big long adventure. 

So, what do I want from a plane-hopping campaign?

  1. Varied and thematic adventure locations.
  2. Home base.
  3. Adventuring is required to unlock other planes.
(This might sound like how the recent God of War games handle the Nine Realms. I am currently playing through Ragnarok, so it is at the forefront of my mind.)

Why MTG? 
    Magic the Gathering has characters that are called Planeswalkers. These characters have a special trait, called a Spark, that allows them to travel from plane to plane and go on these adventures and appear in multiple sets across multiple planes. In recent MTG lore, the MTG equivalent of Thanos from the MCU did the equivalent of snapping his infinity gauntlet and de-sparked or killed many planeswalkers. This was a multiversal story that was a long time coming. Now they have introduced planar gateways called Omenpaths that allow for characters to travel from plane to plane on a much more limited scale. Basically, they got Infinity War'd but there wasn't an Endgame cop out. 

This is where we have two options
  1. Operate Pre-War of the Spark where our characters are planeswalkers and have a spark and can freely plane hop.
  2. Operate Post-War of the Spark where our characters never had/no longer have a spark are rely on the Omenpaths to travel from plane to plane. 
These two options provide drastically different campaigns. The former will have less emphasis on the journey, and more emphasis on the action that's happening there. The latter will flip that, the journey of finding the Omenpath or planar gateway will be a larger part of the adventure. Both are great styles, but every DM has a preferred way to play the game. Personally, I prefer to slow everything down a little bit and let the journey breathe. So for this exercise, I am going to go with the second option. 

This is where I will diverge from MTG lore. Again, this is not an attempt to run a level 1-20 campaign set in the MTG multiverse post-War of the Spark and try and be lore accurate. Instead, I am skimming the top of the ideas that are being presented in Magic to run a fun campaign. 

Campaign Premise: A group of adventurers go on a short adventure (See MTG Pack D&D Adventure), and at the end, they find a key to an Omenpath (or whatever you want to call the Planar Gateway). They would then need to seek out a more knowledgeable NPC about said artifact. When they start poking their nose around and asking questions, two factions arise that both want this artifact. An allied and an enemy faction. The allied faction could potentially be the Harpers since it was in the last adventure. Maybe the enemy faction is the Cult of Bane. You can then choose a few things about this key. Is it tied to a specific plane? Is it general and this gains them access to the liminal space between planes and then get to freely choose their destination? Personally, just to keep the workload down would rather have the former option.

So let's assume we use the adventure from my previous article and we have started in the Forgotten Realms. Now, I get to use the list of MTG planes at the bottom of that article and pick a destination that I want the next adventure to take place. For this, I'm feeling Theros and a Greek Mythos-inspired adventure (notice this is focused on one adventure at a time, not an entire campaign. We will aim to spend 2-4 sessions here and then jump somewhere else.)

Key Campaign Notes so far:
  • Allied Faction: Harpers as planar police?
  • Enemy Faction: Cult of Bane or Cult of Darkness
  • The characters have an Omenpath Key to Theros. Their allies will help them open it and traverse it safely, this time.
Next time I will go through the Adventure Building Process with another pack of cards and see where it takes us!

- Daniel

Sunday, October 29, 2023

MTG Pack D&D Adventure

Random tables are a great traditional way to generate an adventure. Often, I prefer random tables to my own thoughts because it forces me to break out of my habits and regular adventure beats. (When left to my own devices, there will ALWAYS be a necromancer, a dragon, and the Dragonorbs from Dragonlance). 

There are a set of PDFs out there called PlaneShift, put out by WotC. They are mini-settings that give a lot of good lore if you want to play in a MTG setting, but these are only so good as what you can mine from it. So instead of yet another setting book you have to parse through, I am going to provide a better way to use magic

However, I want to provide an alternative to the traditional text-based random tables. - Using a Magic: the Gathering booster pack as a visual random adventure generator. Obvisously, this works best in the MTG-D&D crossover settings, however MTG settings lean heavy on unique themes, vibes, and stereotypes it is easy to pick a MTG set that fits your setting's vibe. 

The best part is, you don't even have to spend any real money on these cards if you don't want to. There are websites that simulate opening packs for you. I like to use this one: https://mtgen.net/

Disclaimer: This is not a hard and fast rule. There are not guarantees when it comes to what you will get in  a pack but it can be a fun way to kick off your imagination through visuals. I do believe it is explained best through an example. For this example, I am going to use the low hanging fruit: The D&D Sets, specifically, Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate. To set this up I went to the link above, selected 1 Set Booster and clicked generate my sets. 

My Cards:


Immediately to many things pop out. There are three main ways to look at these for inspiration; the actual card name, the card art, and the flavor text in italics at the bottom of the cards. Let's outline the key parts to any adventure and see how we can fill these out.

I am first going to walk through each card and draw out something from it.
Ambition's Cost: Seems like a good risk/reward interaction with a sketchy vendor NPC.
Arms of Hadar: Spell prepared by an enemy.
Atrocious Experiement: Potentially the end of the dungeon, the problem of the adventure. Maybe this Jon Irenicus figure could be the main villain.
Bane's Invoker: Easy villain faction.
Chain Devil: Big Boss Monster.
Fireball: Fireball Trap!
Guildsworn Prowler: Allied NPC who is going to help you out during the bar fight.
Jaheira, Friend of the Forest: Allied NPC who gives you the quest. Works for the Harpers.
Luxury Suite: Dungeon location.
Passageway Seer: There is definitely a secret passage in this dungeon!
Plains: Journey to the dungeon.
Scion of Halaster: Necrotic swinging blade trap!
Stoneskin: Spell prepared by an enemy.
Tavern Brawler: Bar fight where we meet Jaheira and are aided by the Guildsworn Prowler.
You're Confronted by Robbers: Encounter on the way to the dungeon.

Now that we have the initial thoughts, lets boil it down to some usable DM Notes.

Quest Hook: Jaheira, a member of the Harpers has contacted the group of adventurers for a job that both she and the guild needs help with. 
Complication 1: A cultist of Bane enters into the bar, Jaheira recognizes this, tells the characters to duck, gives the signal and another Harper starts a bar fight, giving everyone the potential to escape without being seen.
Journey: You are in town, and need to journey about half a day to a noble manor on a farm. Along the way, you get ambushed by some bandits.
Location: The dungeon is in the basement of the farm manor.
5 Room Dungeon: 
    Guardian/Entrance: In the room of the manor that has the trap door that leads down: A group of cultists of Bane. The players should recognize that these are the threat. Cast that Arms of Hadar!
    Puzzle and/or RP Challenge: Trap room! Fireballs and swinging blades. After it all, I would have the sketchy NPC come by, hailing has a friend who just got stuck down here and offers the risk/reward magic item.
    Setback: A dead end! But wait, is that a secret passage?
    Climax: A Chain Devil and a few cultists guard the Atrocious Experiment.
    Loot: The Atrocious Experiment is the plot device that needs to be returned (or not). Sometimes these packs can provide cool artifacts and equipment for loot. I will go ahead and open a few more packs and see what I get. 

Goggles of Night and an Arcane Signet, perfect! Goggles of Night are already statted out, and you get to be creative with the ring. Maybe it provides an additional class resource once per day, leaning into the card's actual ability. 

I do believe, this is runnable! It would probably last 3-4 hours of play, for whatever level you are. If you aren't playing in the realms but something a litte more thematic like Ravenloft, don't fret there are packs you can open. Here is a list of sets to open depending on the theme of your D&D game. The plane will be in parenthesis.

Traditional Fantasy - (Dominaria) - Dominaria, Dominaria Remastered, Dominaria United
Gothic Horror - (Innistrad) - Innistrad: Crimson Vow, Innistrad: Midnight Hunt, Avacyn Restrored, Dark Ascension, Innistrad
Eldritch Horror - (Innistrad) - Eldritch Moon, Shadow's over Innistrad 
Fairy Tales - (Eldraine) - Throne of Eldraine, Wilds of Eldraine
Greek Mythos - (Theros) - Theros, Born of the Gods, Journey into Nyx, Theros: Beyond Death
Giant Cities - (Ravnica) - Ravnica, Guildpact, Dissension, Return to Ravnica, Gatecrash, Dragon's Maze, Guilds of Ravnica
Norse/Vikings - (Kaldhiem) - Kaldhiem
Monster Hunting - (Ikoria) - Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths
Magic School - (Strixhaven) - Strixhaven
Noir - (New Capenna) - Streets of New Capenna
Steampunk - (Kaladesh) - Kaladesh, Aether Revolt
Desert - (Amonkhet) - Amonkhet, Hour of Devastation
Pirates - (Ixalan) - Ixalan, Rivals of Ixalan
Dragons and Tribes - (Tarkir) - Khans of Tarkir, Fate Reforged, Dragons of Tarkir

Bringing it back

 I do believe it is time to bring it back. A lot of life has happened in the past few years. The podcast pittered out, as did the blog, I went back to school to change careers, and I am about to get married! 

All that being said, I need to get writing again. I am working on my masters, so putting words on page is about to be a huge part of my life as I get ready to write my thesis. So, what better way to practice than to write my thoughts into the ether. There was an interview with Stephen King and George R.R. Martin where GRR asked Stephen, "How the heck do you write so many books?" where Stephened basically responded with saying he just has a word goal per day, and writes it. So, my goal for the remainder of the year is instead of waisting time on social media, is to write something. Work on an article, and publish one here at least one day a week. We will see how it goes!

- Daniel

Monday, October 25, 2021

Lore Dump #4 - Folktales of Beverast

Fairies
Somewhere along the countryside, in the middle of the harvest season, a mother reminds her sons "Don't forget to strap your boots down tonight, it's the Eve of Mischief, don't want the fairies to get them!" 

There are said to be parallel realms, entirely different worlds, connected to the World as we know it where creatures such as fairies come from. Fairies, like other creatures from the Feywild, are mischievous little buggers. They are nature's pranksters. 

Dryads
Said to be the sirens of the forest or Mother Nature's vampires, dryads are known for their uncanny ability to charm and lure unsuspecting victims into their groves to devour them. Another creature connected to the Feywild, Dryads often live in solitude and lay claim to large regions as their hunting grounds. Predatory in nature, dryads are also shapeshifters and often appear in a variety of shapes to stalk, lure, and kill their victims. Trees sustain themselves from the sun and rain, dryads sustain themselves on the life essence of the living. 

Trolls
The bastard children of Nature and the Giants, trolls are seen as lowly to giants and outsiders to many of the forest. In the Age of Giants, many trolls served as shamans or druids for their giant kin. Much like nature itself, Trolls are said to be blessed with the ability to regrow and regenerate out of next to nothing. Once the kings of the forest, trolls like many giants, were driven back into caves, mountains and hunted to near extinction. 

- Summaries of the public knowledge collected and spread by the Wardens.

Saturday, October 23, 2021

DM Deep Dive #4 - Running a Published Adventure

Wizards of the Coast has published 15ish ready-to-play 5e adventures at this point. Most are $50, hardback, and sell themselves as all you need to play. I have attempted to run/ran a total of 3 (Lost Mines of Phandelver, Ghosts of Saltmarsh and Curse of Strahd), only having 1 truly good experience. I have a sour taste in my mouth due to a few bad experiences and I’ve learned many lessons along the way and I’ll share them here. 

Lost Mines of Phandelver - my first true adventure I ever ran. It was fun, the group was new, I was new, everything was fresh, and as an adventure it is truly easy to run. Some things are a little convoluted and a certain baddie definitely needs a little buffing up to give the adventure a solid villain, but overall it was a wonderful experience. It’s a good, standard, little bit of everything D&D experience that you can very easily remix with your own content. 

Curse of Strahd (pre-Ravenloft Guide) - Oh boy. Horror is a just as poorly defined as a genre as fantasy. The group, due to wanting tons of secrets and potential for inter-party conflict and drama, ended up with a overzealous 40k Paladin, the son of Dracula, a literal werewolf (found the class on Reddit), blood ritual creepfest sorcerer, and basically Trevor Belmont. Out of the gate I had already homebrewed Byrgenwerth into Barovia, completely rewrote Vallaki, and made it an unfocused and unrecognizable adventure. Strahd became a meme by the 2nd interaction with him, all the tension was gone and we wrapped up Barovia as quickly as possible and went back to good old gonzo kitchen sink fantasy. I truly believe this devolved to insanity because of a mismatch of expectations. 

Ghosts of Saltmarsh - This game probably had the strongest start to any I’ve ever run. I ran the first 3 pretty by the book and everyone was having fun  I didn’t set up the council very well, they didn’t much care for the politics that much, they were in the middle of a murder mystery that took them to Seaton (homebrew adventure), then COVID hit and we stopped playing for a long time then attempted to pick it up right where we left off. Everyone had forgotten what was going on, understandably, we had a small change of characters, so we then jumped ship literally and went to exploring the a jungle with a “only-the”highlights” style speed run of Tomb of Annihilation. The game puttered out about halfway through that due to scheduling.

Current Campaign - I started this campaign with the first chapter of the notorious Tyranny of Dragons. It started with a bang, it had a cool villain, and it was high octane adventuring. I absolutely loved it! I changed motivations to fit the setting, and wrapped up the conflict without it bleeding into 15 levels of questing. It was a great use of a module  

Lessons learned

  1. Modules are wonderful as toolkits to steal chapters, pages, NPCs, quests. 
  2. Modules can work really well if well written and everyone is on the same page going in. 
  3. If you are going to run a module in it’s entirety, make sure you try and keep it in the same spirit as the designers intended and make alterations as you see fit as you go. Don’t rewrite on the front side, that’s way too much work. 
  4. Make sure everyone is on the same page with each other and the DM. The Curse of Strahd party was truly a nightmare, pun intended. 
Hope my experiences and lessons help! Let me know in the comments what you want me to talk about next!

- C&D Daniel


The Great Anglaland Campaign - Session 2 and 3

 Sessions 2 and 3 have come and gone. Here is what the group got up to;   United by their debt to the local barkeep, the party set out to in...